Un salarié domicilié en Autriche agit contre son employeur allemand aux fins de paiement d’arriérés de salaire, d’une indemnité de congés payés et de gratifications dues, devant un tribunal autrichien. Le contrat avait été conclu à Salzbourg. Le travail était censé être effectué à Munich. Mais finalement, aucun travail n’est confié au salarié qui est licenciée. L’incompétence du tribunal autrichien est soulevée, ce qui le conduit à saisir la Cour de Justice.
Le Tribunal se demande tout d’abord si les dispositions protectrices des travailleurs prévues par le Règlement (UE) n° 1215/2012 du 12 décembre 2012 concernant la compétence judiciaire, la reconnaissance et l’exécution des décisions en matière civile et commerciale s’appliquent à un rapport de travail dans le cadre duquel un travailleur, bien qu’ayant conclu un contrat de travail en Autriche, n’a effectué aucun travail tout en s’étant pourtant tenu prêt à travailler.
La Cour, après avoir rappelé que la notion de contrat individuel de travail prévue par l’article 20 du Règlement est une notion autonome, rappelle que cela suppose un lien de subordination à l’égard de l’employeur et qu’une personne doive être « obligée d’accomplir, pendant un certain temps, en faveur d’une autre et sous la direction de celle‑ci, des prestations en contrepartie desquelles elle a le droit de percevoir une rémunération (voir, par analogie, arrêts du 10 septembre 2015, Holterman Ferho Exploitatie e.a., C‑47/14, EU:C:2015:574, points 40 et 41, ainsi que du 11 avril 2019, Bosworth et Hurley, C‑603/17, EU:C:2019:310, points 25 et 26) » (CJUE, 25 fév. 2021, C-804/19,BU contre Markt24 GmbH , point 25»).
La Cour énonce ensuite, ce qui peut sembler évident, que les parties sont liées par un contrat de travail même si celui-ci n’est pas exécuté. Elle juge donc que les dispositions protectrices s’appliquent bien en l’espèce.
Le tribunal autrichien avait également interrogé la Cour sur le point de savoir si les règles autrichiennes de compétence plus favorables au salarié pouvaient être appliquées à la place des dispositions du Règlement UE n° 1215/2012. La réponse négative, retenue par la Cour, était évidente.
La Cour était encore interrogée sur la détermination de la juridiction compétente en vertu de l’article 21 du Règlement. Cet article offre au travailleur plusieurs options pour assigner son employeur. L’article 21 § 1 dispose : « 1. Un employeur domicilié sur le territoire d’un État membre peut être attrait: a) devant les juridictions de l’État membre où il a son domicile; ou b) dans un autre État membre:
- i) devant la juridiction du lieu où ou à partir duquel le travailleur accomplit habituellement son travail ou
devant la juridiction du dernier lieu où il a accompli habituellement son travail; ou
- ii) lorsque le travailleur n’accomplit pas ou n’a pas accompli habituellement son travail dans un même pays, devant la juridiction du lieu où se trouve ou se trouvait l’établisse[1]ment qui a embauché le travailleur »
L’employeur avait son domicile en Allemagne. Il n’avait été assigné en Autriche, juridiction qui pouvait être considérée comme compétente en vertu du b) à condition d’admettre que le travailleur avait accompli habituellement son travail en Autriche ou à partir de l’Autriche. Mais aucun travail n’avait été effectué puisque l’employeur n’avait confié aucun travail au salarié. Le seul indice du lieu de travail était livré par le contrat qui prévoyait que le travail devait être effectué essentiellement à Munich. Selon la Cour : « … la notion de « lieu où le travailleur accomplit habituellement son travail », consacrée à l’article 19, point 2, sous a), du règlement no 44/2001, qui correspond à l’article 21, paragraphe 1, sous b), i), du règlement no 1215/2012, doit être interprétée comme visant le lieu où, ou à partir duquel, le travailleur s’acquitte de fait de l’essentiel de ses obligations à l’égard de son employeur (voir, en ce sens, arrêt du 14 septembre 2017, Nogueira e.a., C‑168/16 et C‑169/16, EU:C:2017:688, point 59). »
La Cour poursuit en ces termes : « lorsque le contrat de travail n’a pas été exécuté, l’intention exprimée par les parties au contrat en ce qui concerne le lieu de cette exécution est, en principe, le seul élément permettant d’établir un lieu de travail habituel aux fins de l’article 21, paragraphe 1, sous b), i), du règlement no 1215/2012. En effet, cette interprétation permet d’assurer au mieux un haut degré de prévisibilité des règles de compétence, le lieu de travail envisagé par les parties dans le contrat de travail étant, en principe, facile à identifier. », ce qui renvoyait en l’espèce à Munich.
Sauf à appliquer l’article 7 5) du Règlement relatif à l’exploitation d’une succursale, la juridiction autrichienne ne pouvait donc être saisie de la demande (CJUE, 25 fév. 2021, C-804/19,BU contre Markt24 GmbH).
levaquin drug
tadalafil india pharmacy
erythromycin 2 gel coupon
toradol for kidney stones
medrol 4mg tablets
buy nolvadex pills
tizanidine brand name in usa
where can i buy feldene gel
levaquin
buy inderal online without prescription
triamterene-hctz 37.5-25 mg
cheap valtrex generic
drug toradol
generic avodart 0.5 mg
medrol pak 4mg
buspar 5
buspar price
how to order valtrex
buy valtrex without a prescription
buy albendazole canada
where to buy tizanidine
propranolol 30 mg
buy valtrex singapore
nolvadex 20 mg cost
buy piroxicam gel
medrol tablets india
cialis offer
medrol 4 mg coupon
nolvadex xt
erythromycin buy
generic feldene
buspar 45 mg
buy albendazole on line
tizanidine 4mg generic
ampicillin iv
trazodone capsule
cheap cialis for sale
generic diflucan prices
buy baclofen pill
baclofen medicine pills
baclofen 10mg tablet
price of albendazole tablet in india
buy cheap dapoxetine online
dapoxetine brand name in india
phenergan price in india
baclofen 30 mg
best online pharmacy propecia
purchase levitra online canada
trazodone 300 mg cost
cost of generic biaxin
erectafil 5mg
tadalafil australia
stromectol order online
buy plaquenil 100mg
augmentin 850 mg
buy ivermectin canada
ivermectin 3
generic lyrica from canada
cost cialis australia
amoxicillin 875 pill
biaxin for uti
purchase finasteride without a prescription
phenergan tablets 10mg
dapoxetine 2018
cost of cialis 5mg pills
buy biaxin 500 mg
buy diflucan canada
plaquenil cost without insurance
generic diflucan online
propecia lowest price
trazodone 150
retin a gel australia
oder trazadone for sleeping
biaxin canada
can i buy albendazole over the counter
trazodone generic cost
buy propecia india
ivermectin 90 mg
tretinoin 0.1 price
albendazole for sale canada
phenergan cream where to buy
diflucan buy in usa
lyrica 150
hydroxychloroquine sulfate tablets
lowest price cialis online
online propecia
augmentin 87
lyrica 300 mg cost
finasteride hair loss
albendazole tablet price
baclofen 30 mg tab
erectafil 5mg
tretinoin 0.05 cost
retin a cream buy online uk
where can i buy tretinoin
lowest price propecia uk
order cialis online pharmacy
drug prices amoxicillin
generic propecia price
ivermectin 2%
cheap stromectol
erectafil 20 for sale
can you purchase amoxicillin online
propecia for sale online
propecia canadian pharmacy
retin a canadian pharmacy
lyrica 100 mg coupon
can you buy cymbalta over the counter
desyrel 50 mg tab
erectafil 20
buy baclofen online canada
albendazole drug
price generic cialis
secure medical online pharmacy
tretinoin 0.0375
propecia 1.25 mg
cheap metformin
albendazole otc uk
baclofen 420 mg
fincar
plaquenil oct
finasteride 5mg over the counter
generic propecia without prescription
Major thankies for the article post. Really Cool.
wellbutrin cost in canada
ivermectin buy australia
buy vermox online usa
where to buy phenergan
baclofen 10 mg pill
tenormin 100 mg tablets
tretinoin cream online uk
erectafil 10 mg
lyrica prices in canada
tadalafil 5mg daily use
amoxicillin cap 500mg price
dapoxetine 60 mg tablet price in india
purchase stromectol online
biaxin xl 500mg
tretinoin drugstore
propecia cost australia
acticin cream
buy cheap trazodone
lioresal generic
plaquenil 250
baclofen for sale
cost for lyrica
trazodone uk buy
ivermectin antiviral
buy generic levaquin
cheapest online pharmacy india
tadacip for sale
tenormin brand name
glucophage 500 mg online
buy lioresal
prazosin 5 mg price
cymbalta online
lipitor price in canada
top 10 pharmacy websites
singulair generic cost
12.5 mg phenergan
brand cialis 40 mg
buy retin a 0.1 online uk
buy online 10mg prednisolone
price of prednisolone 5mg in india
buy baclofen online canada
dexamethasone cost usa
buy prednisolone online
levaquin antibiotic
robaxin 750 tabs
glucophage medication
robaxin 800 mg
discount robaxin
dexamethasone 6mg
atarax for eczema
atarax 50 mg tablet
cost of levaquin
prazosin 6 mg
buy dexamethasone australia
buy lipitor online australia
mail pharmacy
cost of generic lipitor in canada
nolvadex 10 mg
levofloxacin
200 mg cymbalta
37.5 triamterene
baclofen 20 mg tablet price
60 mg cymbalta
where to buy dexamethasone
canadian discount pharmacy
cymbalta australia
buy atarax 10mg
levaquin pill
generic lioresal
best tretinoin cream
90 mg prednisolone
baclofen generic lioresal
atarax over the counter singapore
lipitor generic brand name
Wow, great blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
buying nolvadex uk
buy metformin online pharmacy
tretinoin cream online pharmacy
albendazole 200 mg price
cost baclofen
cymbalta 60 mg cost
tamoxifen online pharmacy
cymbalta prescription coupon
best rated canadian pharmacy
atarax online uk
how much is cialis generic
dexamethasone 80 mg
triamterene 37.25mg
lioresal discount
tretinoin cream prescription online
robaxin otc south africa
dexamethasone 0.25
can you buy robaxin over the counter
antibiotics levaquin
lipitor 5mg
Looking forward to reading more. Great blog. Great.
prazosin for insomnia
metformin tablet price in india
cheap canadian pharmacy
atarax cost
glucophage no prescription
cymbalta price without insurance
A round of applause for your article. Really Cool.
triamterene 75 50 mg
lipitor generic brand name
prednisolone tablets 25mg price
Really enjoyed this blog article.Much thanks again. Great.
tadalafil 30mg
prazosin 5 mg tablets
us pharmacy no prescription
cymbalta 60mg
prazosin 1 mg cap
baclofen medication 10 mg
online pharmacy pain relief
reputable online pharmacy reddit
dexona 4mg tablet
essay help sydney f714ee write my essay college application essay introduction a13pou
ampicillin iv
dexamethasone usa
buy atarax tablets uk
rx pharmacy coupons
robaxin 750 mg tabs
I truly appreciate this blog article. Want more.
products with retin a
where can i get retin a over the counter
canada cialis generic
atarax uk buy
nolvadex 50mg capsules
buy cialis now
Really informative blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
buy nolvadex online no prescription
metformin 25 mg
glucophage 850
rate online pharmacies
purchase levaquin
dexamethasone generic
levaquin buy
levaquin 250mg
prazosin hcl 1mg
baclofen buy uk
lipitor no prescription
cialis mexico
canada cloud pharmacy
sildalis without prescription
southern pharmacy
brand name prednisolone
legit pharmacy websites
atarax pill
azithromycin 600 mg
atarax costs
dexona 4mg tablet online
Say, you got a nice blog article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
hydroxyzine atarax
levaquin cipro
dexona tablet price
albendazole buy online canada
atenolol 60 mg
450mg prednisolone
lipitor prices
atarax pill
tamoxifen 10
cheap cialis 100mg
prazosin erectile dysfunction
baclofen 20 mg pill
atarax medicine 25 mg
phenergan tablets online
I value the post.Really thank you!
the canadian pharmacy
compare pharmacy prices
nolvadex price uk
phenergan australia
prazosin blood pressure
azithromycin price south africa
predisolone online
prazosin bph
baclofen 25 mg tablets
canadian discount pharmacy
levaquin cost
atarax generic cost
Very good post.Much thanks again. Really Great.
10 mg tamoxifen
atarax uk
lipitor 40 mg price in india
dexamethasone buy online
secure medical online pharmacy
levaquin price
average cost of zithromax
lipitor generic price comparison
where can i get accutane online
generic diflucan otc
flomax 400 mcg
online pharmacy pain
buy doxycycline 100mg capsules online
buy phenergan 25mg
generic cost of synthroid
lisinopril 20mg discount
propranolol prescription medicine
I am so grateful for your blog. Keep writing.
diclofenac pills for sale
phenergan 25 cost
buy generic phenergan
legal online pharmacies in the us
how much is lyrica in canada
can you buy albuterol online
augmentin 1g
doxycline
how much is cephalexin
plavix without prescription
price of prednisone
prednisone 40 mg daily
how to buy zithromax
quineprox 750
phenergan online australia
flomax 0.4 mg price
phenergan 25mg otc
phenergan over the counter in uk
bactrim online without rx
buy flucanozole
generic for albuterol
how to buy cephalexin without a prescription
keflex europe
diclofenac gel
suhagra 25 mg buy online india
lisinopril 28 mg
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg capsules
bactrim cost australia
buying doxycycline uk
amoxicillin generic 150 mg
synthroid 37.5 mg
prednisone otc uk
amoxicillin 500 no prescription
drug tizanidine 4mg
azithromycin 500g
Thanks again for the post.Really looking forward to read more.
buy generic accutane
free online slots free online slots play slots
flomax canada
prednisone 60 mg price
buy generic finasteride
accutane for sale without prescription
lisinopril 40mg
cheap diflucan
8 mg flomax
celebrex 200mg price
lyrica 150 mg price australia
prednisone cream rx
canadian celebrex 200mg
flomax for ed
prices bactrim
retino gel
retino
celebrex buy online
buy synthroid over the counter
celebrex best prices
bactrim 80mg 400mg
strattera 40 mg pills
generic amoxil
suhagra
Awesome post.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.
phenergan over the counter uk
where to buy diflucan over the counter
lisinopril 200mg
I am so grateful for your blog article.Much thanks again. Will read on…
Great blog you have here.. Itís hard to find high-quality writing like yours these days. I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!
canadian pharmacy discount coupon
synthroid 88 mcg in india
suhagra 50 mg tablet price in india
synthroid 50 mcg tablet price
how do you take zithromax when to take zithromax z pak used for uti
lisinopril 40 mg india
Touche. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the great work.
buy suhagra 100
doxycycline over the counter usa
prednisone 20 mg price india
Really appreciate you sharing this blog article.Thanks Again. Will read on…
bactrim 160
Greetings! Very helpful advice within thisarticle! It is the little changes that make the biggest changes.Many thanks for sharing!
prednisone in india
diflucan coupon canada
doxycycline price usa
synthroid 250 mcg
buy flomax canada
celebrex 200 mg capsule
cephalexin 500 mg tablet
buy suhagra 100
buy lyrica uk
synthroid 37.5 mg
Hey there! I’m at work surfing around your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the fantastic work!
canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore
cost of lisinopril 10 mg
voltaren gel price in usa
where to get synthroid
cephalexin online
prednisone cream brand name
propranolol online australia
legit pharmacy websites
Hey are using WordPress for your blog platform?I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Doyou need any html coding expertise to make your own blog?Any help would be greatly appreciated!
albuterol 90 mg
24 mg prednisone
retino 0.025
generic for diflucan
bactrim cream
natural remedies for ed ed pills for sale – erection pills that work
buy generic flomax online
diclofenac
lyrica cap 150mg
ordering diflucan without a prescription
zithromax 600
zanaflex 2mg tablets
accutane pills cost
canadian pharmacy cialis
order amoxicillin india
5 mg accutane singapore
noroxin drug
where can you purchase flomax
clopidogrel tabs
diclofenac 50mg price
lisinopril 100 mg
suhagra 50 mg tablet online purchase
how to get diflucan otc
cost of propecia generic
diflucan coupon canada
cost amoxicillin 875 mg
zithromax canada
accutane 40003395956
strattera india
azithromycin pills canada
diflucan over the counter usa
order bactrim ds
where can i buy bactrim
plavix 600 mg
phenergan prices
how to get synthroid
keflex 219
I love what you guys are usually up too. This kind of cleverwork and coverage! Keep up the fantastic works guys I’ve added you guys to my personal blogroll.
lisinopril india
cheap online prescription flomax
suhagra 25
buy vermox in usa
prozac 80 mg
augmentin 14 tablet
buy prednisolone 5mg online uk
celebrex 200 mg costs
gabapentin purchase
silagra
flomax coupon
cheap amoxicillin canada
azithromycin 250 mg otc
generic prozac tablet
buy disulfiram australia
glucophage 1000 mg uk
valtrex generic price canada
I was curious if you ever thought of changing the layout of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or two pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?
silagra 50
celebrex 1
silagra tablets india
cymbalta coupon
paxil cost without insurance
acyclovir pills uk
vermox medication
albendazole albenza
zovirax prescription drug
order propecia online europe
baclofen tablets brand name
buy propecia online no rx
Hi there, everything is going sound here and ofcourse every one is sharing facts, that’s really good, keep up writing.
save on pharmacy
Very good write-up. I definitely love this site. Continue the good
work!
online pharmacy synthroid
Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article.I will make sure to bookmark it and return to read moreof your useful information. Thanks for the post. I will definitely return.
acyclovir cream otc
buy dexamethasone australia
amoxicillin for sale canada
silagra 50 mg tablet
albuterol canadian pharmacy no prescription
buy prozac online no prescription
buy motrin 800 mg
can i purchase phenergan over the counter
baclofen 30 mg capsule
phenergan over the counter usa
how to get antabuse
dexamethasone 20 mg tablet
buy ventolin on line
buy zithromax online australia
prednisolone tablets 25mg
uk pharmacy modafinil
dexamethasone 4 mg price
provigil discount
albendazole buy online
neurontin 100mg tablet
Fastidious answers in return of this matter with real arguments and explaining the whole thing concerning that.
accutane 10mg daily
flomax 0.8
lioresal drug
celebrex 200 mg
cymbalta pills
legitimate mexican pharmacy online
canada rx pharmacy
modafinil 2014
prozac 30 mg tablet
sildalis 120
buy 100 mg silagra tablets
azithromycin 500 mg purchase
Say, you got a nice article. Awesome.
where to get valtrex
silagra pills
silagra 100
cheap finasteride australia
phenergan 10mg cost
provigil online usa
where can i buy tetracycline over the counter
motrin 800 mg cost
zovirax cream over the counter canada
zithromax generic cost
vermox medication
can you purchase azithromycin online
5 mg paxil
Muchos Gracias for your blog article.Really thank you! Want more.
canadian pharmacy silagra
cymbalta price canada
silagra 50 mg price
generic motrin 600 mg
paxil skin rash
reputable canadian online pharmacies
provigil tablet
buy tetracycline capsules
amoxil 500mg capsules
where to buy celebrex cheap
dexamethasone medication
dexona medicine
how to get metformin prescription
zithromax 500 without prescription
purchase valtrex canada
I was recommended this blog by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my problem. You’re amazing! Thanks!
cymbalta 60 mg price canada
motrin 800 mg prescription cost
provigil daily use
all the time i used to read smaller articles or reviews which aswell clear their motive, and that is also happeningwith this paragraph which I am reading at this time.
where can i purchase disulfiram
provigil prescription online
synthroid 50mg
motrin 800 price
albuterol 0.042
modafinil 1000mg
At this time it seems like Drupal is the preferred blogging platformavailable right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you are using on your blog?
pharmacy online 365 discount code
celebrex 200 mg cost
buy accutane online usa
fluoxetine pill
silagra 100
antabuse prescription drug
baclofen 30 mg cream
motrin 500
phenergan 10mg south africa
finasteride buy online
prozac usa
azithromycin 500 mg cost in australia
zovirax pills cost
generic neurontin cost
cheap propecia 1mg
cheap sildalis
vermox mexico
dexamethasone cream
acyclovir 200
cost for celebrex
buy accutane 5 mg
Hello, this weekend is pleasant in support of me, for the reason that this moment i am reading this wonderful informative post here at my house.
phenergan 25mg cream
tetracycline orders without a prescription
cheap sildalis
paroxetine buy online india
flomax 0.8
zithromax 1000 mg for sale
Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News.Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!Many thanksMy blog post – best palm sugar
over the counter paroxetine pills
order paroxetine online
accutane 30 mg
order tetracycline
can you buy vermox over the counter
disulfiram india
zovirax medicine
ventolin 500 mg
valtrex tablets 500mg price
vermox south africa
sildalis in india
motrin